ST MATTHEW'S WESTMINSTER
  • Welcome
  • Livestream
  • Music at St Matthew's
  • Safeguarding

21/11/2012

A Terrible Failure (The Times)

1 Comment

Read Now
 
Picture
Photo: Getty Images


























The Church of England’s vote against women bishops does a disservice to half the population.

Yesterday was a sad and shameful day for the Church of England and therefore for the country of which it is the established religion. It took 12 years of deliberation and prayer for the Church to arrive at its decision on appointing women as bishops, and yet it got that decision dreadfully wrong.

For years to come yesterday’s vote will be felt in the pews and the institutions of the Church as a terrible moral and political failure. The disappointment felt keenly by those on the inside who wanted change will be felt keenly too by those not involved with the Church but who nonetheless see it as a leader for reform and justice.


The Supreme Governor of the Church of England is a woman. In communities up and down the country the Church is sustained by women. To all of these people the Synod yesterday showed disrespect. It did a serious disservice to half the population.

What happened yesterday will be horribly familiar to leaders of political parties that have lost their way. The process was hijacked by a small but highly motivated group of fundamentalists more interested in factional organisation, textual analysis and strict orthodoxy than in the real world and how people live their lives. When such people take over any body it drifts away from common sense.

It happened to the Labour Party in the 1980s and to the Republican Party with the Tea Party in the last four years. The only solution is for moderates to organise themselves and turn their defeats into victories.

This decision was not the one wanted by a majority of the Synod. The Bishops almost all voted to allow women to join their number and 42 of the 44 diocese had voted for it too. It was blocked because there were just enough members of the laity to do the blocking. And these people were not representatives of those who line the pews on the Sabbath.

What this shows, as does the margin of defeat, is that the proposal to have women bishops could have prevailed but did not. The leadership of the Church failed in a fairly straightforward job of political organisation and moral guidance. It has been amateurish and shambolic. And sadly, this provides the epitaph for the outgoing Archbishop of Canterbury.

From the time he was appointed, Rowan Williams has known that winning over the Synod on women bishops would be his great test. But his leadership was too cerebral, too absorbed with his own intellectual anguish. And this is the lamentable result.

Justin Welby will have been hoping for a better start that this. It could, after all, hardly be worse. But at least it provides the new Archbishop with an opportunity to show his mettle. And there are encouraging signs that he may be equal even to the huge task he now faces.

The first thing he has to do is to bring back a simpler, clearer proposal and win. The earliest conceivable time will be in three years when the next Synod is elected and that should be his aim. Perhaps it might take five years. There can be no question of spending a decade slowly pushing the boulder up the hill.

Beyond this though, the incoming Archbishop will need to confront the terrible harm that the vote will have done to the prestige and perceptions of the Church of England. He will need to find words to assuage the anger and address the bewilderment of parishioners at prayer.

And he will need to find a way to ensure that when he next tries to use the weight of his office to give a moral lead — for instance to lecture bankers on their obligations — that weight is still there to use. He should not simply assume that it is. For such weight has to be earned.

Share

1 Comment
Gillian Trewinnard
21/11/2012 12:05:35 pm

It would appear that some with a vote on this matter have put 'not upsetting conservatives' ahead of God's justice and the clear movement of the Holy Spirit throughout the world over the last century and more. Next time there is a vote, I hope the focus is back where it should be. As a kiwi Anglican, I am sad today for the C of E. Commiserations and love.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    Pressmail

    Pressmail is a news service which seeks to keep people informed of comment in the UK concerning current issues in the church.  There is no charge although we encourage subscribers to join the Friends of St Matthew's as a way of supporting our work.

    Subscribe

    Archives

    July 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012

    Categories

    All
    Andrew Brown
    Carlo Martini
    Church Times
    Clifford Longley
    Corporate Ethics
    Gay Marriage
    Jeffrey John
    Jerome Taylor
    John Bingham
    Justin Welby
    Mark Vernon
    Pope
    Richard Coles
    Roman Catholicism
    Rowan Williams
    Taize
    The Guardian
    The Independent
    Theo Hobson
    The Tablet
    The Telegraph
    The Times
    Women Bishops

Privacy & Safeguarding

Privacy Notice
​
Safeguarding

Other websites

St Matthew's School
Conference Centre
History of St Matthew's
Picture


© St Matthew’s Westminster, 2010-20   |   20 Great Peter Street, Westminster, London SW1P 2BU
 +44 (0)20 7222 3704  |  office@stmw.org  | ​
|  School   |   Conference Centre | 
Picture
  • Welcome
  • Livestream
  • Music at St Matthew's
  • Safeguarding